Post Carbon Cities

Skip to content

OTHER POST CARBON INSTITUTE PROGRAMS:   Global Public Media   Relocalization Network   Local Energy Farms   Oil Depletion Protocol   

News

The laws of economics still at play in the oil market
money_100.jpg
Published 7 August 2008 by Vancouver Sun (original article)

The dilemma for governments is that forecasting has such a poor track record that forgoing today's pressing needs to prepare for an uncertain future carries considerable political risk. Making the wrong choices will lead to unfortunate consequences either way.

Published 7 August 2008 by Vancouver Sun, http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/editorial/story.html?id=cb27b4eb-52b0-4028-8095-6804ffba7b64

[This is an EXCERPT: read the whole article here. -Ed.]

"Forecasting is a tough job. People are unpredictable. Technology sometimes holds surprises. Accidents happen. Anything is possible. Inflation might soar, but then real rates of return would decline, and oil producers might choose to leave the resource in the ground, rather than convert it to cash. Central banks might hike interest rates to fight inflation, raising the return on financial instruments, which might persuade producers to pump more, thereby lowering the price of petroleum with increasing supply. The value of the dollar may go up -- or down."

"We don't know how these scenarios will play out."

"Governments face the challenge of introducing legislation without the benefit of foresight. Policymakers must weigh the sacrifices that need to be made in the present to address situations that may, or may not, occur in the future. Many voters want measures that will deal with crime, end homelessness, improve education, relieve traffic congestion, fix the health system, repair or replace infrastructure and provide for child and elder care; tangible issues governments could begin to resolve immediately. The effectiveness of such actions would be apparent and measurable."

"But others warn of future catastrophe caused by human activity and insist government abandon outdated models of economic progress, curtail industrial activity and tax citizens to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide. Only governments, they argue, can impose the changes required to save the planet and the human race. However, there is no way to determine whether any action taken to tackle climate change will be effective."

"The dilemma for governments is that forecasting has such a poor track record that forgoing today's pressing needs to prepare for an uncertain future carries considerable political risk. Making the wrong choices will lead to unfortunate consequences either way."

Photo credit: Scott Thrift

FAIR USE / FAIR DEALING NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material, the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available to advance understanding of certain public interest issues per the 'fair use' provision of United States Copyright Law section 107 and the 'fair dealing' exception of Canadian Copyright Act section 29.


© 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008 Post Carbon Institute

Post Carbon Cities: Helping local governments understand and respond to the challenges of peak oil and global warming.
Post Carbon Cities is a program of Post Carbon Institute, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization incorporated in the United States.